Home Buying Help – Money Management Tools – Home Decorating Ideas – Free Recipes

How to Shut Down Your Mother-in-Law

Ever wish they made mother-in-law muzzles? (Us too.) Until that day comes, here's how to respond to those barbs she's throwin':

MIL: "Oh, you're looking so...healthy [i.e., fat]!"
What you want to say: "So do you, heifer!"
What you should say: "Thank you! I feel great." If she keeps saying it, you can take her aside and say something like, "I'm sure you don't mean to hurt my feelings, but I feel a little self-conscious now." This should end the discussion.

MIL: "Hmm...that's not the way we make chicken."
What you want to say:
"That's because yours sucks."
What you should say: "I'd love for you to try mine this time, if you don't mind." If you'd love one less thing to do and would rather end her critique than argue, say, "Would you
like to make it this time? I could use some help."


MIL: "That's his favorite. Trust me, I've known him a long time."
What you want to say:
"So have I!"
What you should say: "You're probably right. He has all kinds of secrets I haven't learned yet." This shows her that you're not trying to take over (even if you are). It should also end her bragging, since you've kindly reminded her that you're not competing.

MIL: "Is that how you're wearing your hair now?"
What you want to say:
"Don't get me started on your hairspray hive."
What you should say: "Yes, [insert name of spouse] loves it." Say it nicely and your assertiveness might nip her rude comment in the bud -- you won't sound rude either.

MIL: "You buy each other really extravagant gifts."
What you want to say:
"Of course you'd say that...you're cheap."
What you should say: "We love each other. This is one of the ways we show it." Smile with confidence, and her comment will just turn into background noise.

MIL: "Don't treat/talk to my son/daughter that way."
What you want to say:
"Um, last time I checked, you weren't his wife."
What you should say: If she's seen you in an argument, say, "I don't like fighting either, and I'm especially sorry that you had to see it." This ends the discussion and holds your spouse just as accountable for the spat as you are. Or say in a genuine manner, "What am I doing that's upsetting you?" And listen to her answer. If you discover that a behavior pushes her buttons, don't do it -- it'll spare you mucho grief.

Nestperts Tina B. Tessina, PhD, author of It Ends with You: Grow Up and Out of Dysfunction, and women's lifestyle expert Harriette Cole
More in-law advice:
>> Mother-in-laws uncensored
>> Weekend survival kit: Hosting the in-laws
>> 5 In-law issues solved

Check out what your MIL is saying about YOU!

-- The Nest Editors

Dec 29, 2009

See More: Couple Issues , Family & In-Laws , Love & Sex

share your opinion on this topic
Want to participate? Log in to share your thoughts.

Beautiful advice! This year we made it clear a few weeks in advance that we would spend either Christmas Eve or Christmas Day with the family and spend the other day, just the two us. The beautiful thing...we let them decide which day was more important to them. Making the plans in advance really helped us have peace of mind!

by Dasguptah on Dec 18, 2008

Thanks for these tips. What do you say though, when your MIL is completely out of line? Over Thanksgiving she actually said "Did someone punch you in the face? Oh, I'm sorry I didn't realize those were dark circles under your eyes." When it's an outright attack like that, I have no idea what to say and it has made me extremely anxious about having to spend time with her this Christmas.

by katm12981 on Dec 18, 2008

Or what about when your MIL says something like, "Don't you think you'd like to wear black? It's so much more slimming on you."

by cneidertusa on Dec 18, 2008

Haha! These are all probably much, um, sweeter than I would be :) Thankfully my MIL is a relatively non-confrontational person. I don't think she would ever have the guts to say anything negative towards me.

by Mrs. Bean on Feb 10, 2009

This would have been much more helpful if it had said something like how to get your Monster-in-Law to not be so obsessive over something that doesn’t exsist (IE “her Grand-babies”.) I’ve had her verbally threaten me over children my husband and I aren’t sure we even want to have. Oh, and maybe how to cut the cord from your son… that would also be quite helpful in the next issue!

by dnm200 on Apr 08, 2009