• The Knot
  • The Nest
  • The Bump

Money Q&A: Claiming Tax Exemptions?

Q.

The Nest Q&A How many exemptions should we claim, and how much can we deduct?

A.

Assuming that you're filing together (which you should do as a married couple unless one of you has crazy medical expenses or has defaulted on a loan), you have three choices for filing: zero, one, or two exemptions.

Zero Exemptions

If you have a high combined taxable income (more than $164,550, and are therefore in a 28 percent or higher tax bracket), and have taxable investment income, claim "Married, 0." That means more is getting taken out of your paycheck each month, so you'll owe less money (if at all) to the government come tax time.

One Exemption

If both of you are working, you have minimal investment income, and your combined taxable income is less than $164,550, you each should claim "Married, 1." When you file, you'll likely break even or get a small surplus back.

Two Exemptions

If only one of you is working and your taxable income is less than $164,550, the employed spouse should claim "Married, 2." You'll likely break even or get a small surplus back.

As far as deductions go, the standard deduction for married couples filing jointly is scheduled to be $11,400 for the 2009 tax year. If you're renting and have no other deductions that exceed $11,400, you'll get this deduction next year. But if you're deducting mortgage interest and real estate taxes and they exceed more than $11,400, itemize those deductions on your tax return.

Make sure to check out our interactive tax translator!

Nestpert Philip Camporeale, CPA in New York City

-- The Nest Editors

Mar 11, 2010

See More: Money Q&A , Money

share your opinion on this topic
Want to participate? Log in to share your thoughts.

the instructions on the W-4 sheet are wrong. do NOT blindly follow the directions on the W-4 sheet. my h and I each have one job. he makes slightly more than I do, but not that much more. we thought we were being conservative and marked married with one exemption on our W-4s for 08. we even bought a house last year. we saved as much as we could toward retirement. now it looks like we owe over 10k in federal taxes. Looking at our witholding last year compared to when we were filing singly with 2 allowances, the witholding was far far below what it should have been. Please be careful and ask someone for help or go to the IRS website to figure out how much you should actually have witheld.

by mrs.larry on Feb 23, 2009

My husband and I both claimed Married 0 and we still owe about $1500.

by Jen and Mark on Mar 12, 2009

I'm confused. My fiance and I both work. When we get married should we each claim 1 or 0? I'd rather have more money taken out during the year then owe money when taxes are due.

by JennaLee85 on Jul 26, 2009

Wow, my husband and I file married filing single, we have one dependent and a house. However, I do not want to owe the government. I rather just pay more now then later. We get a nice refund most of the time.

by JNL$LSM on Jan 08, 2010

Yes, it's confusing, but it's not the 1950's anymore. when you select married on your W-4 you are basically saying you are the employed spouse... therefore taking out less taxes because you are supporting two people on one salary. Check the next box over on your W-4 "Married (But withhold at the higher single rate)" this will cut in deeper to what you take home (like when you were single) but you should be alright for tax time.

by dhardman013 on Mar 30, 2010

My husband and I both claimed married 1, and it was a huge mistake. Only 5% of his income was taxed, and about 9% of mine. We ended up owing $1500. Always claim as little as you can, if you can afford it! Expensive lesson learned.

by kmonaghan on Apr 01, 2010

My husband and I filed married filing single with 0 withheld. This worked out well we got a very good return. We don't like to owe the government anything at the end of the year.

by MOONIE7580 on Oct 20, 2010

You have to be married on the last day of the tax year to claim a tax exemption for your spouse on your tax return. If your child was born alive on or before December 31st, and all five of the tax exemption tests are met, you can take a dependency tax exemption on your tax return. You can also take the Child Tax Credit on your tax return. Val - forex consultant.

by tuningval on May 12, 2011

Taxes have always been problematic for me to handle and that is why I ask for help with a tax resolution specialist. It's the safe way for me to have my taxes submitted on time and taking advantage of all the benefits and exemptions.

by misterloftcraft on Sep 02, 2011